
AD
We had a really fun “half-day Friday” a few weeks ago at Nanny’s house. Aunty Ceri was home, and after a lovely lunch, we played board games. It was the perfect opportunity to play a new game for us, Red Herrings Puzzle Game from Happy Puzzle. Read on to find out more about Red Herrings Puzzle Game, how to play and our thoughts:

About Red Herrings Puzzle Game
Match What You See To What You Hear!
Each of the 400 challenge cards features eight colour-coded clues and five answers. The answers to six of the eight clues will form pairs of homonyms (sounding the same, spelt the same way, but with different meanings). The remaining two answers are the ‘red herrings’. They will be homophones (sounding the same, but spelt differently and with different meanings). Your task is to identify the two homophones within 30 seconds to score points. Be the only player to find the red herrings and you will score a double win! Some clues are easy, some more tricky to match, with a few pitfalls to watch out for; some clues may seem to work together as a pair but will not work if they invalidate another pair and therefore will not be counted as a correct answer. Once the timer runs out, all players immediately remove their screen to reveal the two colours they believe to be the red herrings. Then turn over the card to reveal the solution! Absolutely brilliant!
Red Herrings currently costs £19.99 from Happy Puzzle company and other good retailers.
It is suitable for ages 10 to adult and can be played by 2 to 4 players.

How to Play the Red Herrings Puzzle Game (by Happy Puzzle)
If you enjoy word games that challenge your logic and attention to detail, Red Herrings by Happy Puzzle is a fun and surprisingly tricky choice. The goal is simple—but don’t be fooled. The game is designed to mislead you along the way.

Objective
The aim of the game is to correctly identify the two “red herrings” on each card. These are clues that sound like they belong but are actually incorrect.

Game Components
Each game includes a deck of cards, player screens, coloured counters, and a timer.

Setup
Each player takes a screen and a set of coloured counters. Shuffle the cards and place them down within reach of all players.

How to Play
Take the top card and stand it up so all players can see the eight colour-coded clues. Each card contains six clues that form three correct pairs, and two clues that are red herrings based on homophones.
Once the card is revealed, start the timer. Players study the clues and decide which two are the red herrings. Each player selects the two corresponding coloured counters and places them in front of them, hidden behind their screen.
When time is up, all players reveal their chosen counters simultaneously by lifting or removing their screens.

Scoring
Players score points for correctly identifying the red herrings. If a player is the only one to identify both red herrings in a round correctly, they receive a bonus point.

Winning the Game
The game continues with new cards until one player reaches ten points. That player is the winner.
Notes
Players must keep their selections hidden behind their screens until the reveal. Only the two incorrect clues should be chosen, not the correct pairs. Speed and careful thinking are important, as the homophones are designed to mislead.

Our Thoughts on Red Herrings Puzzle Game
Red Herrings from Happy Puzzle Company is a high-quality, engaging word game that is quick and easy to set up. At first, we found it a little confusing, needing a couple of practice rounds, without scoring and the timer, before we really got the hang of it. Once we did, playing competitively became a lot of fun.
My only suggestion for the game is that I’d prefer it if all the colour counters were more distinct from each other- I found the dark orange and red counters very similar.
The game challenges you to correctly identify the two “red herrings” on each card, which are designed to mislead you. This makes it both educational and entertaining—helping players learn new words and meanings, understand homophones, and playfully practise logical thinking.

It’s perfect for families of all ages (recommended for children aged 10 and over, but decide based on your child’s word knowledge). Everyone enjoyed it, and the mix of learning, laughter, and friendly competition kept us engaged from start to finish. We all had a great time and are already looking forward to playing again.

A Tip for Red Herrings
A helpful tip for playing Red Herrings by Happy Puzzle Company is to pay close attention to the sound and meaning of each word. The challenges rely on homonyms (words that sound the same but have different meanings) or homophones (words that sound alike but are spelt differently). Take your time to think about all possible meanings before making a choice, and don’t be fooled by words that look or sound familiar—they might be the “red herrings” designed to trick you. Practising a few rounds helps you spot patterns faster and makes the game more fun and rewarding.
With younger children: After each round, go through the different meanings of the words so children learn for next time.

Red Herrings Puzzle Game: In Summary
Red Herrings is an engaging and educational puzzle game that challenges players to spot the correct answers while avoiding misleading options. It encourages careful observation, flexible thinking, and problem-solving, making it suitable for players of all ages. The game is easy to set up and highly replayable, combining learning with fun and keeping everyone entertained with its clever mix of tricky wordplay and playful challenge.

We recommend Red Herrings to add to your family game collection if you love word games like us!
Have you played Red Herrings before? Do you love word games?
Read more: Toy and Game posts
Watch our Red Herrings Puzzle Game below: